Last night I set up the TV to watch some of the BBC White Season on my cheap old free view recorder. There has been a lot of who-ha regarding this series of programmes , especially from the left, so I thought I would give my take.
As a paid up member of the 'white' working class (I have always wanted to say that!) I found the idea of
documenting working people in this way
intensely patronising. This is clearly middle class people giving a middle class slant on what they see as working class people.It is fuel for the far right nationalist bigots in the
BNP to peddle their hate and division. It is a far cry from the method of say film director Ken
Loach who says more in his films about UK working class life and culture than these BBC
documentor's do. The fact that most of the 'liberal' middle class have been writing off the working class as not existing anymore, for the past 15 odd years is lost to these people. The working class, the class of low paid employees, have never gone away.
I want to have a pop at one particular part of the series and what it was trying to interpret. It was the one about immigration (mainly Polish and eastern
Europeans) in
Peterborough. The reporter interviewed about three white job seekers who
wouldn't take on the jobs migrants were doing and stated clearly that they would rather be on benefits. It was very staged. Only three?
Surely to make the point more, hundreds of white workers would have had to be interviewed in order to make the point that white workers are lazy benefit scroungers!! Clearly not the case but the middle class point was made.
In my entire working career I think I can count so called benefit scrounger I have met, on one hand. What I can count is the huge amount of workers who have been disenfranchised by the monotony of low paid unskilled work that they cant escape from.We have a situation today of historically low unemployment. What we do have is an
abundance of low paid menial jobs, protected by the abysmally low minimum wage that is benefiting migrant workers escaping poverty in their own countries. UK White workers would and have done, the same
themselves if there was a higher wage country elsewhere and mass unemployment here.
The programme showed migrant workers working every hour under the sun. Well anyone care to cast their minds back to the 80s would remember that after a few years on the dole , earning nothing and receiving meagre benefits, you would have worked every hour under the sun the first job you got. This is exactly what these migrant workers are doing. From £250 a month, if they had a job back in the east , to £250 per week plus in the UK. F*ck me no wonder all the hours under the sun are being worked.First job I got in 1986 after a year on the dole I was working a six day week and all the overtime under the sun.
And
don't the employers love it, just like that stone mason employer in the documentary.
Employers
don't want UK labour. They want migrant Labour because its on offer and cheap. Its a deliberate strategy by the capitalists and the government to bring jobs down to the lowest pay possible so that white workers who over the last 50 years have fought and won good working conditions will have eventually no choice but to take the crap. Meanwhile employers make and will continue to make huge profits.
With union membership at around about 30% workers are still in a weak position to improve things. Unions should and are organising amongst the low paid to bring them together under a common agenda. Workers are currently going to achieve a lot more this way than relying on voting as the low turnouts in elections show. With a Labour government which still leans on the finance(through the unions) and the votes of working people things
aren't any better (could they get any worse with recession round the corner? Didnt someone say boom and bust had ended?)
The White Season just further reinforces the day to day discrimination working class people suffer at the hands of the liberal middle class media. I am surprised Billy Bragg had anything to do with it.
Enjoy Seamus Milne's comment from this weeks Guardian. New Labour wake up.
Don't give the election to Cameron.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2008/mar/13/budget.economy